Be Truthful
After serious deliberations and
contemplation, I could come to a conclusion, to discuss this issue which has
been disturbing me for the last couple of months. But a few experiences of the
recent days compelled me to write perhaps prematurely. However, I am sure with
the feedback from the teachers, parents and the focus group that is the
students, we shall be able to reach to some conclusion and also find some
solution. As many people feel that the children are the reflection of their
parents and the teachers, this worries me more. I happened to interact with a few
children in some matter related to discipline and following the norms which
help them to exploit their potential in the best possible manner. There may be a few kids who tend to get
influenced by negative thoughts of the people around them. We all are human
beings and all tend to commit mistakes which most of the times is done
unknowingly and without any ill intention but sometimes deliberately. Some of
the students who came to me because of some act of indiscipline were asked
simple questions related to the things which they had brought to the school. They
knew it very well that mobile phones are not allowed in the School but still
got them. The first reaction of most of the kids is that it was left in his/her
bag by mistake. When probed further they stick to the same statement till the
parents are asked to come to the school. In many a cases, it was found that the
parents had not provided the mobile phone to the child and he still had it. The
parents are taken by surprise in the majority of the cases because they think
their child to be very sincere and honest who shared all secrets with them. In
most of the cases, the parents have been very supportive and they helped us in
the best possible manner so that the children come out of the habit of telling
a lie. We promote that the children should admit whatever they did
and the matter should end once they realize their mistakes, rather than lingering it for long. We are not at all
fond of any type of punishment and that should be avoided to the last till it
becomes mandatory for the betterment of the children. Punishment may not be the
best of the solution of such problems in all cases. My worry in such cases has
been that despite the fact that the parents are so much concerned about their
children and try to be as easily available to them as possible, then why such
children also tend to tell a lie? What is that which makes the kids to do what
they should not do and they may not like to do? Whose fault is this and if
somebody is to be punished who should that be? These are the questions which
need to be answered. We tried to search for the answers but without much of success.
Though the psychologists and educationists advocate that the children should be
handled carefully and I fully agree with them. But the problem is that when
children demand for certain things which may not be age appropriate and of
proper use to them and the parents say no for that, then the reaction of the
children is very unpleasant and negative. Some parents have told me that they
tried to be very polite to their child but that did not make any difference
rather made him more arrogant and he become a habitual offender. The incidence
of a big city in which many children were found in a place abhorrent for them,
should be an eye opener for all of us.
When I discussed this issue with the
teachers, parents and the students, most of them seemed to be in agreement that
there was a quandary and that needed to be tackled immediately. The reasons told for the cause of children
resorting to not telling the truth or avoiding the parents and teachers were
also shared and I would like to cite a few of them. Some teachers and parents
felt that as there is a lot of competition in today’s time and the parents
expect a lot from their kids so they tend to tell a lie when they could not
perform up to the expectations of the parents because they do not want them to feel
bad or let down. This appears to be correct because the children who do not
perform well in test/examination avoid sharing their performance with the
parents. If the parents would not have been very fussy about the grades/marks
then the children would have not avoided sharing the true performance. In some
other cases, the aura or the position or the status of the parents is so big
that their children are not supposed to perform or behave below a particular
standard and they are always expected by their parents to be at the top without
fail. This also contributes to the stress of the children. The other reason
shared by the parents, teachers and also the children was that, as the adults
also tend to tell a lie at times either in personal life or the professional,
so they feel that there was nothing wrong in doing that. The other factor
mentioned by many was the overall environment in the society. The children
mentioned that even media was also responsible for that because the negative
characters are projected more prominently than the other ones. The behavior of
our representatives is also a major reason because the kids listen to them and
tend to follow them considering that this was the easy and appropriate way of
succeeding in life. Many of the children feel that the peer pressure is also a
major cause because showing off is also considered to be one way of becoming
popular amongst the friends.
These reasons are some of those which
might be forcing our children to get involved in those activities which may not
be good for them as well as the society but we must think beyond that also. At
times, the parents and the teachers reach to a point of frustration which
further aggravates the problem. The most important remedy for all this can be
to have realistic expectations from our children so that they do not come under
undue pressure. The education system should be such that it gives opportunity
to every child to grow. The education should not be considered as the mere
means for earning money but also learning to live the life in all kinds of
situation good as well as appalling. They should be told firmly about the
things acceptable in the society. They should also be made aware of their
duties in addition to their rights. The children should also be encouraged to
respect the rights of the other people. The use of electronic tools should be
limited to the minimum requirement. The parents should become the role model
for the kids because the kind of values received in the family play a noteworthy
role in the life of the children and this cannot be overemphasized.
Though the issue raised may appear to
be not very significant but this is the one which causes rest of the problems
and disturbances. So, this is the responsibility of all to address this issue
and make our children healthier citizens of the nation.
I am glad to read these observations. I am not sure if I am eligible to write my thoughts here but still think that the solutions may look difficult but may not be impossible. Competition is certainly a reason for it. But more is the parent's expectation. Now because the child has to project himself as per their expectations he starts with small lies. I can think of something which may be worth trying by all of us -
ReplyDelete1. Parents and teachers should think twice before they tell any lie.
2. Parents should convince the child for any "no" on child's demand.
3. Sometime we do not want to discuss some of the things with children just to save our time.
4. Some incentives at school level to the students who follow code of conduct.
5. Sharing of responsibilities may be one of the solutions.
These are just some of the observations but will think over it more....
Dr Vivek Vijay
IIT Jodhpur
I agree with you sir..The three major influences today which impress children the most..the teachers , the parents, the media should understand their code of conduct so that kids are not misguided .I hope everyone understands the importance of respecting others right and learns to be sensitive to each others feelings too.I agree with Dr Vivek Vijay that parents should convince their child for a 'NO' if the demand is not justified.
ReplyDelete