Justified and judicious use of rights for development
Our country is going through many
reforms, be it the economic, social or education sector. It has been
discussed earlier also and the debate is still going on as far as the educational
reforms are concerned. The introduction of CCE by the Central Board of Secondary Education
and the introduction of RTE by the central government are two important and
major steps taken by the government. Government is making efforts on its part
to make all stake holders aware of the advantage to the larger section of the
society. Let us first focus on the issue which has been taken up by CBSE
schools only. CCE has a holistic approach for the development of the child`s
personality. Proper implementation of the same can bring out the best in a
child. But there are a few problems which are faced by the people whether they
are the teachers, students or the parents. The first is that not all people are
aware of the real meaning and the process of the newly introduced evaluation
system. This is because it was introduced at a fast pace without giving proper
time to all the stake holders to understand it well. Though there have been efforts
in that direction but the reality is that even after being in existence, there are
many parents who do not know about the same. The second issue is the lack of resources in many schools. When I write resources, it is both human resource
and the material resource in the form of infrastructure. We know that CCE gives a lot of importance on record keeping. The activity and the project or anything else used for the
evaluation would have to be produced for the sake of transparency. The parents
have even asked for the record of the oral test taken by the teacher in the beginning
of the session. Though it is good for the children but the challenge is the strength of the students in the class. This would be very good and comparatively
easy for the teachers if the number of students in the class are limited (ideal
number would be twenty to twenty five and not more than that). The third
important requirement is of the textual material and the support material for
the children and the teachers because the books available in the market are not
exhaustive enough to make a perfect learning. The teachers and the children do need some proper material
to comprehend the system well. These things should be taken care of on
priority. Otherwise people have a feeling that CCE has made
children and the teachers little indifferent towards proper learning.
The other reform has been a boon
for all the children who were deprived of education because of the social or
economic reason. Now all children from the age of six years to fourteen years
have a right to free and compulsory education. By the year 2013 all schools
including the government schools, will have to create minimum facilities and
the infrastructure so that the aims and the objectives of the act could be realized
in the real sense. The act has provisions to streamline the school education and
make it more student friendly. The act advocates the involvement of the
parents by giving them the responsibility in the school management committees.
The qualification of the teachers has been specifically defined and they will
have to adhere to it by the year 2015.But what has been observed in the last
two years is that maximum focus has been on the admission of the weaker group
children in private schools. Even the officials are also very keen and excited for the same and their enthusiasm makes us feel happy. But the same kind of
enthusiasm and excitement is not there when it comes to thinking about the government
schools. The real objectives of the act cannot be achieved unless the whole act
is taken as a unit. The act does not advocate about the right to free and
compulsory education of the children from weaker section but for all the
children irrespective of the family or social background. I have been wondering
and sharing the same with everyone that it is good that twenty five percent children
from disadvantaged group are given the opportunity to study with other group of
the children and it would really be beneficial for both in the long run despite
there being few problems of adjustment initially. But my worry is that a school
cannot admit more than a particular number in the class so these twenty five
percent children would be accommodated at the cost of other twenty five percent.
Now where will these children ( who are deprived of admission) go? It has happened as if you have taken the share of one child and given to the other one. When all children have the right
to free education then why the children from so called sound family background
be deprived of good education. The government would do the justice to all
children by increasing the number of good schools and also improving the
quality of existing schools. The teachers of the government schools will have
to be left free of any other job but teaching in the schools. Proper scientific
and objective monitoring of the schools should be undertaken and that should
not be left to the desire and wishes of individuals made responsible for seeing
the proper implementation of the act. I think it would be good idea if some
qualified NGOs are involved in this field to monitor the implementation of the
act.CCE and RTE can change the whole
education scenario for the benefit of the children and all should make their efforts
to see that these reforms succeed.
I would end the article by sharing
something which should be taken by all seriously that in any reform or act, the
interest of all concerned should be given due importance. Here I would like to
talk specifically for the teachers. All know it well that corporal punishment to
the children is prohibited in the schools. Most of the teachers do follow the
same but sometimes some teachers do get indulged in something which is not acceptable.
Somebody shared with me the following
incident. A child had slapped a teacher in the class and then he complained to
the authorities that the teacher was disturbing him. When the case was heard
the child told in confidence that the teacher was asking him to study and he
never wanted to do that and that was the reason for his act. Then he brought into light a startling fact, that our educational board and the government is really so kind because they are absolutely child friendly, all laws and acts say that teachers cannot give corporal punishment but
tell me where it is mention that a child cannot slap or misbehave with the teacher.The society can not prosper and progress unless there is a justified use of liberty and rights. If this is not done then a mayhem might be created and situation may go beyond control. With this I am rest my views for your thoughts and feedback.
In my opininion we need to do the exact opposite of what the RTE and CCE propose.I am afraid the CCE provisions are going to build a nation of underachievers who are barely ready for college and a swathe of disillusioned kids living under the euphoria of their scores .
ReplyDeleteOn any given day I would advocate to toughen standards A tough regime of standardized tests even in every class is of utmost importance. It gives a concrete goal towards which teachers can work to, and a yardstick to measure teacher and school performance.A standardized test is the ultimate equalizer. No face control. Just you, your hard work, a random number , and the question paper. For that moment, for many the first moment; your caste, community, region counts for nothing.
We use catchy slogans imported from the west – such as “No child left behind” – but only the slogan is imported the substance is conveniently ignored. The fact that standardized testing is the cornerstone of America’s NCLB program is ignored. The US government uses the results of these tests to monitor school performance. while all the way till Class XII the Indian government has no way to tell if government schools are working. Internal grades and CCE don’t throw up any meaningful data and it has just given rise to ‘bunching at the top phenomenon’ . The best way to make everyone happy is to simply move the mean scores toward the top, This has increased the number of high performers in the 90 percent-plus category swelled by 30 percent to 21,665 from 16,563 last year. The number of students scoring 95 percent and above also reached a new high — almost doubling to 2,097 from 1,202 in 2010. Little wonder, good cheer and euphoria all around.
Honestly , We will increasingly view islands of excellence in India with suspicion while admiring Berkeley and Johns Hopkins.The need is to make schools accessible and quality conscious by state investment not by seeking charity or punishing private players.